Wolf Man Avatar Posted on 3/23/2012 by Wolf Man
Movies
Blu-ray/DVD Review
Share This Story
Doesn't come close to being the most faithful adaptation of the classic story, but still action-packed popcorn fun that works much better at home on Blu-ray.

Those who are looking for a fun, action packed popcorn movie will most likely enjoy this amplified version of The Three Musketeers, as there’s plenty of sword fighting, explosions, and other daring-do to keep most entertained. It's pretty much the version you thought we'd get from director Paul W.S. Anderson, who manages to wring as much action from Dumas' story as possible, with a likable cast that does an admirable job. The results may stretch the limits of plausibility and definitely won't impress those hoping for a faithful literary adaptation, but it's far from the worst adaptation we've seen. If any of that sounds like your kind of movie, let this Blu-ray swashbuckle its way into your collection, as there’s plenty of crazy fun to be had here.
Release: March 13, 2012
Rating: PG-13
Studio: Summit Entertainment
Written by Chris Mitchell (senior editor)

There have been plenty of film adaptations of the classic Three Musketeers story, from the impressive 1993 Disney movie that many still hold in high regard to this day, to 2001’s The Musketeer, which had some pretty amazing fight scenes but suffered from sub-par acting. Now famed action director Paul W.S. Anderson (Mortal Kombat, Resident Evil) brings us his take on the famous tale by injecting his unique style of action and effects to bring viewers an intense popcorn flick that gives the classic story a nice kick in the pants that’s sure to excite and entertain most - just as long as you're not expecting classic literature between all those explosions.

Many will be quick to point out its significant flaws and ultimately compare it to any of the several renditions of Alexandre Dumas' eternal classic, fellow reviewer Chris Pandolfi among them, and here's a snippet of what he felt about the theatrical version (check out his full review right HERE:)

"The Three Musketeers plays less like an adaptation of Alexandre Dumas’ original novel and more like a test drive for a new historical video game. Indeed, it was directed by Paul W.S. Anderson, whose career is in part defined by films based on video games (Mortal Kombat, Alien vs. Predator, the first and third Resident Evil films with another one on the way). It’s not the deviations that bother me; I truly could not care less how unfaithful a film is from its source so long as I’m being entertained. What bothers me is the simple-mindedness with which the story is told. This new The Three Musketeers – with its exaggerated stunt work, silly steampunk special effects, and awful twenty-first century dialogue – is an adequate film for fifteen-year-old gamers who have not seen any previous adaptation, never read the novel, and barely glanced at the CliffNotes."

I’m pretty sure there’s plenty of people who will find plenty of faults to point out in this film, but as long as you’re not expecting Shakespeare-quality performances and enjoy action and adventure, you’ll more than likely enjoy the ride here as I did. Especially here on Blu-ray, as the film’s transfer is done exceptionally well here. Every color and detail shows up perfectly, from the flying dirt particles and debris of explosions, to the fancy sword hilts shown throughout the movie, everything is seen with crystal clarity. The impressive 5.1 DTS-HD audio is just as exciting, as every bass filled explosion and sword clang is heard loud and clear.

There’s a few swashbuckling special features to look into here, as audio commentary with director Paul W.S. Anderson and producers Jeremy Bolt and Robert Kulzer kick things off. The three of them talk about everything from filming locations, to the special effects, and even some of the changes they added to the book’s story. Those curious about all the little details are sure to get a kick out of this. Four small featurettes give viewers even more details into the movie’s creation as they cover certain effect scenes, Orlando Bloom’s casting, and more. “Deleted & Extended Scenes” show off twelve deleted and extended sequences that can be viewed together as a 14-minute feature or separately. “Access: Three Musketeers” is a nice scene specific supplement that plays along with the film and lets you check out featurettes, behind-the-scenes footage, trivia, and more.

Those who are looking for a fun, action packed popcorn movie will most likely enjoy this amplified version of The Three Musketeers, as there’s plenty of sword fighting, explosions, and other daring-do to keep most entertained. It's pretty much the version you thought we'd get from director Paul W.S. Anderson, who manages to wring as much action from Dumas' story as possible, with a likable cast that does an admirable job. The results may stretch the limits of plausibility and definitely won't impress those hoping for a faithful literary adaptation, but it's far from the worst adaptation we've seen. If any of that sounds like your kind of movie, let this Blu-ray swashbuckle its way into your collection, as there’s plenty of crazy fun to be had here.


Share This Story





Like its 2009 predecessor, J.J. Abrams reduces Gene Roddenberry's once exciting and idealistic vision to the level of meaningless summer popcorn thrills.
May 17, 2013Read More!
Under Luhrmann's direction, Fitzgerald's novel is freed from the weight of its literariness; there's an energy that has never been seen before, a vibrancy, a sense that we’re actually being told a story.
May 11, 2013Read More!
While light on content, this Kaijudo starter DVD makes a good place for curious new fans to get acquainted with the hit animated series.
May 10, 2013Read More!
A nice collection of Nickelodeon's popular shows starring recognizable friends and well-intentioned lessons for preschool viewers and their parents.
May 10, 2013Read More!
Although the film is good-natured fun, it cannot compare to the original 2008 film, which still ranks as one of the greatest superhero films ever made.
May 1, 2013Read More!
See More From Movies...
We chat with Viviane Schwarz, author + illustrator of the dazzling new graphic novel The Sleepwalkers. All Ages Welcome.
May 9, 2013Read More!
Beautifully illustrated in both style and substance; rewards those who give in to its infectious sense of optimism in discovering one’s own place in the world.
May 8, 2013Read More!
We chat with the multi-talented author and artist of Calling Dr. Laura: A Graphic Memoir about life, love, and following your dreams.
April 26, 2013Read More!
We chat with author Ted Kosmatka about his latest novel, Prophet of Bones, what it’s like working for Valve, and writing intelligent fiction.
April 26, 2013Read More!
Sedaris' latest collection of essays is as good as they’ve ever, filled with the same observational humor and honesty that's helped endear him to so many.
April 26, 2013Read More!
See More From Culture...
April sales rained down 42% hardware and 17% software losses YOY, with total dollars spent down a gloomy 25% overall.
May 17, 2013Read More!
A slapdash collection of the same pitfalls seen in the original game, choosing to bask in gimmickry and momentum from fans rather than creating a stable and engrossing experience.
May 15, 2013Read More!
A more accessible experience for those who might have struggled with the first two games, and a considerable improvement over the original release.
May 3, 2013Read More!
In no way perfect, but still an excellent entry to the world of DC Universe as well as an exciting fighting game with fan favorites and a narrative to keep players engaged.
April 26, 2013Read More!
Mars' wrath continued as hardware sales fell 32% YOY, while software managed a slight gain of 2% off a string of high-profile releases.
April 19, 2013Read More!
See More From Games...